Monday, January 9, 2012

Stock Market Returns for Election Years .......“I'll be surprised if the U.S. gets through the first quarter without a downturn.” – John Hussman, PhD


In case you have been living under a rock – this is an election year.  Here’s a table of election-year stock-market returns since 1928. 

Many follow the “Presidential Cycle.”  The average return has been about 12% in election years.  There have only been 3-down years in the 21 election years since 1928. 

Of course, like 2008, we still have to worry about recession.  (In the 1966 Bear market, both peaks and troughs seemed to cycle rougly every 4-years, so perhaps this year will fool all of the pundits (including my previous commentary) and give us another down year as we head down to a MAJOR bottom in 2013.  The last major trough was in 2009.

Regarding the many pundits and talking heads on CNBC who suggest that we won’t have a recession because important economic data points look better, John Hussman wrote in his latest commentary: “Very simply, neither a strong monthly employment gain nor a slight uptick in the PMI are informative signals that recession risk has eased...the data set (not just a few points of data) continues to imply a nearly immediate global economic downturn.  Lakshman Achuthan of the Economic Cycle Research Institute (ECRI) has noted if the U.S. gets through the second quarter of this year without falling into recession, "then, we're wrong." Frankly, I'll be surprised if the U.S. gets through the first quarter without a downturn.” – Weekly Market Comment, John Hussman, PhD, at http://www.hussmanfunds.com/.

That’s a very disconcerting comment, especially when you read the Mr. Hussman’s entire commentary.  Mr. Hussman, PhD, presents a typically, rigorous and analytic approach to the question of oncoming recession. His comments can’t be dismissed, but he does present some possible scenarios in which US recession might be avoided.

I don’t pretend to be an economist, so a few layman comments follow.  There have been some concerns recently that might corroborate Mr. Hussman’s views:  (1) The Holiday retail numbers weren’t as good as initially reported for many retailers.  Except for the high end, retail-buyers were late with their purchases and bought after retailers discounted heavily.  (2) A few pundits have suggested that the pre-releases of earnings have been trending down.  When it comes to stock prices, it’s all about the earnings. Another important data point is consumer confidence.

When it comes to consumer confidence – you can read the tea leaves either way.  Consumer confidence has been improving since October.  The Consumer Confidence from the Conference Board now stands at 64.5.  While the direction is good (up for the past 2-months), the overall number isn’t great and is at levels frequently seen in recession.

Here is a chart from an article titled, “Consumer Confidence at an Eight-Month High”, By Doug Short, posted December 27, 2011.  Full article at http://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/updates/Conference-Board-Consumer-Confidence-Index.php

If consumer confidence continues to improve significantly, I don’t think we’ll see a recession; but what do I know – I’m an Engineer.  My financial expertise, if you can call it that, is analyzing the S&P 500 via the Navigate the Stock Market computer program.

Today the NTSM analysis slipped to HOLD.

I bought back into the stock market at S&P 500, 1155 on 7 Oct after the 6 Oct NTSM buy signal.  I remain 100% long in the long term portfolio (100% stocks in the 401k.). (See the page “How to Use the NTSM System” – the link is on the right side of this page). 

I am 90% long in the trading portfolio.

Just a reminder: 100% invested in stocks is way too much for most rational folks.   Don’t do it unless you have a high tolerance for risk.